Update: Video fixed.
-
Subscribe
3,200 subscribers. 10,000 daily views.
Recent Comments
Shawn Abbott: I have already gave several examples of why Christianity is different you just dont seem... The Top 30 Atheist/Agnostic/Skeptic Blogs
Lessica: If God was really going for clarity, he would have waited for the invention of Lojban. He must have... The Book Burning That Wasn’t
Heidi: And before that we had rocks! And we were damned glad to get them! My dad went to school in a... Indianapolis Schools Ban Atheism Websites
1minion: That was going to be my question, Jerdog. Do some good with all that “evil” stuff for a... The Book Burning That Wasn’t
Phil E. Drifter: Schools teach conformity. They teach you to sit down and shut up and be quiet and be... Indianapolis Schools Ban Atheism Websites
Nelly: ditto The Book Burning That Wasn’t
Anthony D Jacques: I love how God saying “Thou Shalt Not Kill” comes off so Do as I say, not as I do. Christians are... Pray for Obama
-
12 Comments
The guy at 2:33 is pretty insane.
Sorry, 20:33.
Actually, never mind. He’s talking about people like that who are insane.
It’s hard to understand him, give me a break. :(
Heh, funny way to start a thread … DDM having a conversation with DDM’s self :)
I wonder if they intended the chorus line at 6:27.
I think the arbitrator did a great job, and I think some of the speakers were really articulate. I loved the point of the Hindu guy about it all being a red herring, that talking about tolerance is just code for “we know we’re right and you’ll find out too when you die.”
I think Dawkin’s missed his point when he was trying to talk apostacy and the death penalty. I think what he was trying to talk about is how if you teach a child that leaving their religion is a crime they will be executed for, then how can you honestly say that they’re choosing to be in the religion. But he wasn’t able to express that in this format.
I also thought it was very interesting watching the Abrahamic folks sidle around their attitudes towards things they seemed to know are culturally unacceptable.
A very civilized discussion, since fortunately there were no evangelical bible-thumpers present to vent their views of multiple sins, hell-fire and damnation.
It took Dawkins several attempts to get the Muslim cleric to admit that punishment for apostasy [defection] within tradtional Islam is death.
“Catholicism teaches me to respect other religions” – WHEN?!?!?!?
Every single acquaintance of mine who has gone to Catholic school has reported that they teach a pretty comprehensive “and all those other guys” course which is pretty sharp on the details of tradition and the broad strokes of belief, but gets more dicey when it comes to history (especially when that history involves interaction with Christendom). My father, on the other hand, also attended Catholic school back in the day and this was not a part of the curriculum. Perhaps a fairly recent innovation?
Anyone wonder why the ’school kids’ are still in their uniform?
Didn’t get a chance to change before going onto the show??
I think that first rabbi who spoke actually had the best argument, and that it was never really refuted. frankly i dont think that dawkins was a shining star at all in this debate. he did well, but he tended to go off message a little. still, the debate overall was wonderful.